Changes to the Code
H.R. 4054 · Accreditation Choice and Innovation Act · Reported The text a committee sent back to its chamber, often with changes, recommending a vote.
Reported by committee · step 2 of 5
20 U.S.C. § 1011c National Advisory Committee on Institutional Quality and Integrity
12 changes the bill asks for here, 9 carried out
- Carried out:
in paragraph (2), by redesignating subparagraphs (A) through (C) as clauses (i) through (iii), respectively, and adjusting the margins accordingly;
- Not carried out:
by striking Individuals and inserting the following:(A) In general.— Individuals;
§ 1011c(b) already has provisions of its own, so its opening words can't simply become the first of them.
Technical detail
/us/usc/t20/s1011c/b has provisions already, so its words can't become the first - Carried out:
in clause (ii), as so redesignated, by striking
and training
and insertingand skills development
; - Not carried out:
by adding at the end of paragraph (2) the following:
(B) Disqualification.— No individual may be appointed as a member of the Committee if such individual has a significant conflict of interest, such as being a current regulator (such as a State authorizer), that would require the individual to frequently be recused from serving as a member of the Committee.; and
We can't read how this instruction is worded yet, so it isn't shown in the text.
Technical detail
no-pattern: adding at the end of paragraph (X) the following: QCONTENT; and - Carried out:
by striking
Except as provided in paragraph (5), the term
and insertingThe term
; and - Carried out:
by adding at the end the following:
If, during a term of office of a member of the Committee, the member has a changed circumstance that results in such member having a significant conflict of interest (as described in paragraph (2)(B)), such member shall vacate such office and a new member shall be appointed to serve the remainder of such term in accordance with this paragraph.
; - Carried out:
in paragraph (4), by adding
and
at the end; - Carried out:
in paragraph (5), by striking
; and
at the end and inserting a period; and - Carried out:
by striking paragraph (6);
- Not carried out:
in subsection (d)(2), by inserting at the end the following:
The name of any member of the Committee who has been recused with respect to an agenda item of the meeting shall be included in such agenda.
;We can't read how this instruction is worded yet, so it isn't shown in the text.
Technical detail
no-pattern: inserting at the end the following: QTEXT; - Carried out:
in subsection (e)(2)(D), by striking
, including any additional functions established by the Secretary through regulation
; and - Carried out:
in subsection (f), by striking
September 30, 2021
and insertingSeptember 30, 2028
.
§ 1011c(b)Membership(1)–(5)
Start of § 1011c to (b)(1)(B) unchanged ·
(C) six members shall be appointed by the President pro tempore of the Senate, three of whom shall be appointed on the recommendation of the majority leader of the Senate, and three of whom shall be appointed on the recommendation of the minority leader of the Senate.
(2) Qualifications Individuals shall be appointed as members of the Committee—
[struck: (A)] [inserted: (i)] on the basis of the individuals’ experience, integrity, impartiality, and good judgment;
[struck: (B)] [inserted: (ii)] from among individuals who are representatives of, or knowledgeable concerning, education and [struck: training][inserted: skills] [inserted: development ]beyond secondary education, representing all sectors and types of institutions of higher education (as defined in section 1002 of this title); and
[struck: (C)] [inserted: (iii)] on the basis of the individuals’ technical qualifications, professional standing, and demonstrated knowledge in the fields of accreditation and administration in higher education.
(3) Terms of members [struck: Except][inserted: The] [struck: as provided in paragraph (5), the ]term of office of each member of the Committee shall be for six years, except that any member appointed to fill a vacancy occurring prior to the expiration of the term for which the member’s predecessor was appointed shall be appointed for the remainder of such term.[inserted: If, during a term of office of a member of the Committee, the member has a changed circumstance that results in such member having a significant conflict of interest (as described in paragraph (2)(B)), such member shall vacate such office and a new member shall be appointed to serve the remainder of such term in accordance with this paragraph.]
(4) Vacancy A vacancy on the Committee shall be filled in the same manner as the original appointment was made not later than 90 days after the vacancy occurs. If a vacancy occurs in a position to be filled by the Secretary, the Secretary shall publish a Federal Register notice soliciting nominations for the position not later than 30 days after being notified of the vacancy.
(5) Initial terms The terms of office for the initial members of the Committee shall be—
§ 1011c(c)–(d)
(b)(5)(A)–(c)(2) unchanged ·
(3) advise the Secretary with respect to the preparation and publication of the list of nationally recognized accrediting agencies and associations;
(4) advise the Secretary with respect to the eligibility and certification process for institutions of higher education under subchapter IV, together with recommendations for improvements in such process;[inserted: and]
(5) advise the Secretary with respect to the relationship between—
(A) accreditation of institutions of higher education and the certification and eligibility of such institutions; and
(B) State licensing responsibilities with respect to such institutions[struck: ; and][inserted: .]
[struck: (6)] [struck: carry out such other advisory functions relating to accreditation and institutional eligibility as the Secretary may prescribe by regulation.]
(d) Meeting procedures
(1) Schedule
(A) Biannual meetings The Committee shall meet not less often than twice each year, at the call of the Chairperson.
§ 1011c(e)–(f)
(d)(1)(B)–(e)(2)(B) unchanged ·
(C) a list of the members of the Committee; and
(D) a list of the functions of the Committee[struck: , including any additional functions established by the Secretary through regulation].
(f) Termination The Committee shall terminate on September 30, [struck: 2021][inserted: 2028].
20 U.S.C. § 1099b Recognition of accrediting agency or association
40 changes the bill asks for here, 39 carried out
- Carried out:
in the matter preceding paragraph (1), in the first sentence, by striking
or training
and insertingor skills development
; - Carried out:
by amending paragraph (1) to read as follows:
(1) the accrediting agency or association (other than an accrediting agency or association described in paragraph (2)(D)) shall be a State or national agency or association and shall demonstrate the ability to operate as an institutional or programmatic accrediting agency or …
- Carried out:
in clause (i), by striking
principal
; and - Carried out:
in clause (ii), by striking
its principal
and insertinga
; and - Carried out:
in subparagraph (B), by striking
or
at the end; - Carried out:
by striking
its principal
and insertinga
; and - Carried out:
by inserting
or
at the end; and - Carried out:
by adding at the end the following:
(D) is an entity (such as an industry-specific quality assurance entity) that has been— (i) determined by a State to be a reliable authority as to the quality of education or skills development offered in such State for the purposes of this Act; and (ii) designated (in …
- Carried out:
by amending subparagraph (A) to read as follows:
(A) subparagraph (A), (C), or (D) of paragraph (2), then such agency or association is— (i) distinctly incorporated or organized; and (ii) both administratively and financially separate from, and independent of, any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or …
- Carried out:
by striking
or
at the end of subparagraph (B); and - Carried out:
by striking subparagraph (C);
- Carried out:
by inserting
(in the manner described in subparagraph (B))
afterreligious missions
; and - Carried out:
by striking
and
at the end; and - Carried out:
by striking subparagraph (B) and inserting the following:
(B) such accrediting agency or association consistently applies and enforces standards that respect the stated religious mission of an institution of higher education by— (i) basing decisions regarding accreditation and preaccreditation on the standards of accreditation of such …
- Carried out:
by amending subparagraph (A) to read as follows:
(A) success with respect to student achievement outcomes in relation to the institution’s mission and to the programs the institution offers, or the mission of a specific degree, certificate, or credential program, which may include different standards for different institutions …
- Carried out:
by amending subparagraph (I) to read as follows:
(I) record of student complaints received by, or available to, the agency or association, and the institution’s process for resolving complaints against the institution; and;
- Carried out:
in the matter following subparagraph (J), by striking
subparagraphs (A), (H), and (J)
and insertingsubparagraph (J)
; and - Carried out:
in paragraph (6)(A)(ii), by inserting before the semicolon at the end the following:
(including any student complaints received by, or available to, the agency or association)
. - Carried out:
Subsection (b) of section 496 of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1099b) is amended to read as follows:
(b) Secretarial requirements and authority.— (1) State designated accrediting agency.— (A) Approval of state plans.— The Secretary shall— (i) if a State’s plan with respect to the State’s designation of an entity as an accrediting agency or association for the purposes described …
- Carried out:
by inserting
(which may vary based on institutional risk consistent with policies promulgated by the agency or association to determine such risk and interval frequency as authorized under subsection (p))
afterintervals
; and - Carried out:
by striking
, including those regarding distance education
. - Carried out:
by redesignating paragraphs (2) through (9) as paragraphs (3) through (10), respectively; and
- Carried out:
by inserting after paragraph (1) the following:
(2) develops a policy process to identify any institution or program of study accredited by the agency or association that is not meeting the standards for accreditation of the agency or association, with a focus on the standards assessing an institution’s or program of study’s …
- Carried out:
Paragraph (5) of section 496(c) of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1099b(c)) (as redesignated by paragraph (2)(A)) is amended to read as follows:
(5) establishes and applies or maintains policies to ensure that any substantive change of an institution described in subparagraph (B) after the agency or association has granted the institution accreditation or preaccreditation status does not adversely affect the capacity of …
- Carried out:
in the matter preceding subparagraph (A), by inserting
, on the agency’s or association’s website,
afterpublic
; and - Carried out:
in subparagraph (C), by inserting before the semicolon at the end the following:
, and a summary of why such action was taken or such placement was made
;
- Carried out:
in paragraph (9) (as so redesignated), by striking
and
at the end; - Not carried out:
in paragraph (10)(B) (as so redesignated), by striking the period at the end and inserting the following:
, including an assurance that the institution does not deny a transfer of credit based solely on the accreditation of the institution at which the credit was earned;
; andWe can't read how this instruction is worded yet, so it isn't shown in the text.
Technical detail
no-pattern: striking the period at the end and inserting the following: QTEXT; and - Carried out:
by adding at the end the following:
(11) such agency or association shall make publicly available, on the agency or association’s website, a list of the institutions of higher education or program of study accredited by such agency or association, which includes, with respect to each such institution or program of …
- Carried out:
Section 496(c) of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1099b(c)) is further amended by adding at the end the following:
(12) confirms that the standards for accreditation of the agency or association do not assess the roles (including actions or statements) of elected and appointed State and Federal officials and legislative bodies; and.
- Carried out:
Section 496(c) of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1099b(c)) is further amended by adding at the end the following:
(13) confirms that an institution’s or program of study’s compliance with a standard for accreditation of the agency or association does not require the institution or program to take any action (such as developing a new program of study) that would result in a violation of any …
- Carried out:
Section 496 of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1099b) is further amended by amending subsection (g) to read as follows:
(g) Limitation on scope of criteria.— (1) In general.— The Secretary shall not establish criteria for accrediting agencies or associations that are not required by this section. (2) Institutional eligibility.— An institution that is in compliance with the standards of its …
- Carried out:
Section 496 of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1099b) is further amended by amending subsection (h) to read as follows:
(h) Change of accrediting agency or association.— (1) In general.— With respect to an institution or program of study that is not subject to a covered action and that seeks to change its accrediting agency or association for a reason not related to any such covered action (such …
- Carried out:
Section 496 of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1099b) is further amended by amending subsection (i) to read as follows:
(i) Dual accreditation rule.— (1) Recognition by secretary.— The Secretary shall recognize the accreditation of any otherwise eligible institution of higher education if the institution of higher education is accredited, as an institution, by more than one accrediting agency or …
- Carried out:
Section 496 of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1099b) is further amended by amending subsection (k) to read as follows:
(k) Religious institution rule.— (1) In general.— Notwithstanding subsection (j), the Secretary shall allow an institution that has had its accreditation withdrawn, revoked, or otherwise terminated, or has voluntarily withdrawn from an accreditation agency, to remain certified …
- Carried out:
Section 496(n)(3) of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1099b(n)(3)) is amended by striking the last sentence.
- Carried out:
Section 496(o) of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1099b(o)) is amended by inserting before the period at the end the following:
, or with respect to the policies and procedures of an accreditation agency or association described in paragraph (2) or (5) of subsection (c) or how the agency or association carries out such policies and procedures
.
- Carried out:
by striking subsections (p) and (q); and
- Carried out:
by adding at the end the following:
(p) Risk-based or differentiated review processes or procedures.— (1) In general.— Notwithstanding any other provision of law (including subsection (a)(4)(A)), an accrediting agency or association shall establish risk-based processes or procedures for assessing compliance with …
- Carried out:
Section 496 of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1099b) is further amended by adding at the end the following:
(q) Definitions.— For purposes of this section: (1) Program length.— The term ‘program length’ means the minimum amount of time in weeks, months, or years that is specified in the catalog, marketing materials, or other official publications of an institution of higher education …
§ 1099b(a)
§ 1099b. Recognition of accrediting agency or association
(a) Criteria required No accrediting agency or association may be determined by the Secretary to be a reliable authority as to the quality of education or [struck: training][inserted: skills] [inserted: development ]offered for the purposes of this chapter or for other Federal purposes, unless the agency or association meets criteria established by the Secretary pursuant to this section. The Secretary shall, after notice and opportunity for a hearing, establish criteria for such determinations. Such criteria shall include an appropriate measure or measures of student achievement. Such criteria shall require that—
(1) the accrediting agency or association [inserted: (other than an accrediting agency or association described in paragraph (2)(D)) ]shall be a State[struck: ,] [struck: regional, ]or national agency or association and shall demonstrate the ability [struck: and the experience ]to operate as an [inserted: institutional or programmatic ]accrediting agency or association within the State[struck: ,] [struck: region, ]or nationally, as appropriate;
(2) such agency or association—
(A)
(i) for the purpose of participation in programs under this chapter, has a voluntary membership of institutions of higher education and has as a [struck: principal ]purpose the accrediting of institutions of higher education; or
(ii) for the purpose of participation in other programs administered by the Department of Education or other Federal agencies, has a voluntary membership and has as [struck: its][inserted: a] [struck: principal ]purpose the accrediting of institutions of higher education or programs;
(B) is a State agency approved by the Secretary for the purpose described in subparagraph (A);[struck: or]
(C) is an agency or association that, for the purpose of determining eligibility for student assistance under this subchapter, conducts accreditation through (i) a voluntary membership organization of individuals participating in a profession, or (ii) an agency or association which has as [struck: its][inserted: a] [struck: principal ]purpose the accreditation of programs within institutions, which institutions are accredited by another agency or association recognized by the Secretary;[inserted: or]
(D) [inserted: is an entity (such as an industry-specific quality assurance entity) that has been—]
(i) [inserted: determined by a State to be a reliable authority as to the quality of education or skills development offered in such State for the purposes of this Act; and]
(ii) [inserted: designated (in accordance with subsection (b)(1)) by such State as an accrediting agency or association with respect to such State for such purposes;]
(3) if such agency or association is an agency or association described in—
(A) [inserted: subparagraph (A), (C), or (D) of paragraph (2), then such agency or association is—]
(i) [inserted: distinctly incorporated or organized; and]
(ii) [inserted: both administratively and financially separate from, and independent of, any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or membership organization, by ensuring that—]
(I) [inserted: the members of the board or governing body of the accrediting agency or association are not elected or selected by the board or chief executive officer (or the representative of such board or officer) of any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or membership organization;]
(II) [inserted: among the membership of the board or governing body of the accrediting agency or association—]
(aa) [inserted: if such board or body is comprised of 5 or fewer members, there is a minimum of one member who is not also a member of any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or membership organization (referred to in this subclause as a “public member”) and who represents business (such as an owner of a business (including a small business), a chief executive or operating officer of a business, or another other business executive or employer with optimum policymaking or hiring authority); and]
(bb) [inserted: if such board or body is comprised of 6 or more members, there is a minimum of 2 public members (at least one of whom represents business (as described in item (aa))) for every 6 members;]
(III) [inserted: guidelines are established for such members to avoid conflicts of interest, including specific guidelines to ensure that no such member is an employee of any institution accredited by the agency or association or has a financial interest in any such institution;]
(IV) [inserted: dues to the accrediting agency or association are paid separately from any dues paid to any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or membership organization; and]
(V) [inserted: the budget of the accrediting agency or association is developed, determined, and maintained by the accrediting agency or association without any review by, consultation with, or approval by any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or membership organization; or]
[struck: subparagraph (A)(i) of paragraph (2), then such agency or association is separate and independent, both administratively and financially of any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or membership organization;]
(B) subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2), then such agency or association has been recognized by the Secretary on or before October 1, 1991;[struck: or]
[struck: (C)] [struck: subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) and such agency or association has been recognized by the Secretary on or before October 1, 1991, then the Secretary may waive the requirement that such agency or association is separate and independent, both administratively and financially of any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or membership organization upon a demonstration that the existing relationship has not served to compromise the independence of its accreditation process;]
(4)
(A) such agency or association consistently applies and enforces standards that respect the stated mission of the institution of higher education, including religious missions[inserted: (in the manner described in subparagraph (B))], and that ensure that the courses or programs of instruction, training, or study offered by the institution of higher education, including distance education or correspondence courses or programs, are of sufficient quality to achieve, for the duration of the accreditation period, the stated objective for which the courses or the programs are offered;[struck: and]
(B) [struck: if ]such [inserted: accrediting ]agency or association [struck: has][inserted: consistently] [struck: or][inserted: applies] [struck: seeks][inserted: and] [struck: to][inserted: enforces] [struck: include][inserted: standards] [struck: within][inserted: that] [struck: its][inserted: respect] [struck: scope][inserted: the] [struck: of][inserted: stated] [struck: recognition][inserted: religious] [struck: the][inserted: mission] [struck: evaluation ]of [struck: the][inserted: an] [struck: quality][inserted: institution] of [struck: institutions][inserted: higher] [struck: or programs offering distance ]education [struck: or correspondence education, such agency or association shall, in addition to meeting the other requirements of this subpart, demonstrate to the Secretary that][inserted: by]—
(i) [inserted: basing decisions regarding accreditation and preaccreditation on the standards of accreditation of such agency or association; and]
[struck: the agency or association’s standards effectively address the quality of an institution’s distance education or correspondence education in the areas identified in paragraph (5), except that—]
[struck: (I)] [struck: the agency or association shall not be required to have separate standards, procedures, or policies for the evaluation of distance education or correspondence education institutions or programs in order to meet the requirements of this subparagraph; and]
[struck: (II)] [struck: in the case that the agency or association is recognized by the Secretary, the agency or association shall not be required to obtain the approval of the Secretary to expand its scope of accreditation to include distance education or correspondence education, provided that the agency or association notifies the Secretary in writing of the change in scope; and]
(ii) [struck: the][inserted: not] [struck: agency][inserted: using] [struck: or][inserted: as] [struck: association][inserted: a] [struck: requires][inserted: negative] [struck: an][inserted: factor] [inserted: the ]institution[inserted: ’s] [struck: that][inserted: religious] [struck: offers][inserted: mission] [struck: distance][inserted: based] [struck: education][inserted: policies,] [struck: or][inserted: decisions,] [struck: correspondence][inserted: and] [struck: education][inserted: practices] [struck: to][inserted: in] [struck: have][inserted: the] [struck: processes][inserted: areas] [struck: through][inserted: covered] [struck: which][inserted: by] [struck: the][inserted: subparagraphs] [struck: institution][inserted: (B),] [struck: establishes][inserted: (C),] [struck: that][inserted: (D),] [struck: the][inserted: (E),] [struck: student][inserted: and] [struck: who][inserted: (F)] [struck: registers][inserted: of] [struck: in][inserted: paragraph] [struck: a][inserted: (5),] [struck: distance][inserted: except] [struck: education][inserted: that] [inserted: the agency ]or [struck: correspondence][inserted: association] [struck: education][inserted: may] [struck: course][inserted: require] [inserted: that the institution’s ]or [inserted: a ]program [struck: is][inserted: of] [struck: the][inserted: study’s] [struck: same][inserted: curricula] [struck: student][inserted: include] [struck: who][inserted: all] [struck: participates][inserted: core] [struck: in][inserted: components] [struck: and][inserted: required] [struck: completes][inserted: by] the [struck: program][inserted: agency] [struck: and][inserted: or] [struck: receives][inserted: association] [inserted: that are not inconsistent with ]the [struck: academic][inserted: institution’s] [struck: credit][inserted: religious mission];[inserted: and]
(C) [inserted: such agency or association demonstrates the ability to review, evaluate, and assess the quality of any instruction delivery model or method such agency or association has or seeks to include within its scope of recognition, without giving preference to or differentially treating (such as through separate standards, procedures, or policies) a particular instruction delivery model or method offered by an institution or program, except that in a case in which an instruction delivery model allows for the separation of the student from the instructor, the agency or association requires the institution to have processes—]
(i) [inserted: through which the institution establishes that the student who registers in a course or program with such an instruction delivery model is the same student who participates in the course or program of study (including, to the extent practicable, the testing or other assessments required under the course or program of study), completes the course or program of study, and receives the academic credit for such course or program of study; and]
(ii) [inserted: which are implemented in a manner that is minimally burdensome to the student;]
(5) the standards for accreditation of the agency or association assess the institution’s—
(A) [inserted: success with respect to student achievement outcomes in relation to the institution’s mission and to the programs the institution offers, or the mission of a specific degree, certificate, or credential program, which may include different standards for different institutions or programs of study, and which shall include—]
(i) [inserted: standards for consideration of student success outcomes measures, including—]
(I) [inserted: a comparison of the median total price charged to students in a program of study student cohort to the value-added earnings of such cohort;]
(II) [inserted: completion rates;]
(III) [inserted: retention rates; and]
(IV) [inserted: loan repayment rates;]
(ii) [inserted: standards for consideration of learning outcomes measures (such as competency attainment and licensing examination passage rates); and]
(iii) [inserted: standards for consideration of labor market outcomes measures (such as employability measures, earnings gains, or other similar approaches);]
[struck: success with respect to student achievement in relation to the institution’s mission, which may include different standards for different institutions or programs, as established by the institution, including, as appropriate, consideration of State licensing examinations, consideration of course completion, and job placement rates;]
(B) curricula;
(C) faculty;
§ 1099b(a)Criteria required(5)–(6)
(a)(5)(D)–(G) unchanged ·
(H) measures of program length and the objectives of the degrees or credentials offered;
(I) record of student complaints received by, or available to, the agency or association[inserted: , and the institution’s process for resolving complaints against the institution]; and
(J) record of compliance with its program responsibilities under this subchapter based on the most recent student loan default rate data provided by the Secretary, the results of financial or compliance audits, program reviews, and such other information as the Secretary may provide to the agency or association;
except that [struck: subparagraphs][inserted: subparagraph] ([struck: A), (H), and (]J) shall not apply to agencies or associations described in paragraph (2)(A)(ii) of this subsection;
(6) such an agency or association shall establish and apply review procedures throughout the accrediting process, including evaluation and withdrawal proceedings, which comply with due process procedures that provide—
(A) for adequate written specification of—
(i) requirements, including clear standards for an institution of higher education or program to be accredited; and
(ii) identified deficiencies at the institution or program examined[inserted: (including any student complaints received by, or available to, the agency or association)];
(B) for sufficient opportunity for a written response, by an institution or program, regarding any deficiencies identified by the agency or association to be considered by the agency or association—
(i) within a timeframe determined by the agency or association; and
§ 1099b(a)–(l)
(a)(6)(B)(ii)–(G) unchanged ·
(7) such agency or association shall notify the Secretary and the appropriate State licensing or authorizing agency within 30 days of the accreditation of an institution or any final denial, withdrawal, suspension, or termination of accreditation or placement on probation of an institution, together with any other adverse action taken with respect to an institution; and
(8) such agency or association shall make available to the public, upon request, and to the Secretary, and the State licensing or authorizing agency a summary of any review resulting in a final accrediting decision involving denial, termination, or suspension of accreditation, together with the comments of the affected institution.
(b) [struck: “Separate][inserted: Secretarial] [inserted: requirements ]and [struck: independent” defined][inserted: authority.—] [struck: For the purpose of subsection (a)(3), the term “separate and independent” means that—]
(1) [inserted: State designated accrediting agency.—]
(A) [inserted: Approval of state plans.—] [inserted: The Secretary shall—]
(i) [inserted: if a State’s plan with respect to the State’s designation of an entity as an accrediting agency or association for the purposes described in subsection (a)(2)(D) includes each of the elements listed in subparagraph (B)—]
(I) [inserted: subject to clause (ii)(I), approve the State’s designation of such entity as such accrediting agency or association for the purposes described in subsection (a)(2)(D) for a 5-year period, beginning not later than 30 days after receipt of the plan from such State with respect to such designation;]
(II) [inserted: submit to the State and the authorizing committees, and make publicly available, the Secretary’s response to the State with respect to such plan, including whether the plan includes each of the elements listed in subparagraph (B); and]
(III) [inserted: publish in the Federal Register, with a 30-day public comment period, the plan submitted by such State with respect to such designation, and the Secretary’s response to such plan; and]
(ii) [inserted: if, not later than 30 days after the 30-day public comment period referred to in clause (i)(III), a State revises the State’s plan approved under clause (i)(I) to incorporate one or more of the comments received during such 30-day comment period, and such revised plan includes each of the elements listed in subparagraph (B)—]
(I) [inserted: revise the 5-year period described in clause (i)(I) approving the State’s designation of the entity as an accrediting agency or association for the purposes described in subsection (a)(2)(D) to begin not later than 30 days after receipt of such revised plan;]
(II) [inserted: submit to the State and the authorizing committees, and make publicly available, the Secretary’s response to the State with respect to such revised plan, including whether such revised plan includes each of the elements listed in subparagraph (B); and]
(III) [inserted: publish in the Federal Register, such revised State plan, and the Secretary’s response to such revised State plan.]
(B) [inserted: Required plan elements.—] [inserted: The required elements of a State plan submitted under subparagraph (A) with respect to the designation of an entity as an accrediting agency or association are as follows:]
(i) [inserted: A description of the process the State used to select the entity for such designation.]
(ii) [inserted: A justification of the State’s decision to select the entity for such designation.]
(iii) [inserted: A description of any requirements (in addition to the requirements of this section), that the State required the entity to comply with as a condition of receiving and maintaining such designation, including a requirement for the entity to use, to the extent practicable during such designation, the common terminology developed pursuant to paragraph (3).]
(iv) [inserted: A copy of the standards, policies, and procedures of the entity that the State considered in selecting the entity for such designation.]
(v) [inserted: The State’s assessment of how the standards for accreditation of the entity will be effective in meeting the requirements of subsection (a)(5).]
(vi) [inserted: Evidence that at least one other State has determined that such entity is a reliable authority as to the quality of education offered for the purposes of this Act.]
(vii) [inserted: An assurance that the State will comply with the monitoring requirements described in subparagraph (C).]
(C) [inserted: State monitoring.—]
(i) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: A State that has designated an entity as an accrediting agency or association for the purposes described in subsection (a)(2)(D) shall submit to the Secretary, and to the State authorizing entity, as appropriate, a report at the end of the 5-year period for which the entity has received such designation, which shall include, with respect to each program of study or institution that has been accredited by such entity during such period, and disaggregated by type of credential, certification, or degree—]
(I) [inserted: the number and percentage of students who have successfully obtained a postsecondary education credential, certification, or degree offered by such program or institution;]
(II) [inserted: the number and percentage of students who were enrolled and did not successfully obtain such a credential, certification, or degree within 150 percent of the program length; and]
(III) [inserted: the results of the State’s assessment described in subparagraph (B)(v).]
(ii) [inserted: Counting transfer students.—] [inserted: For purposes of clause (i)(I), a student shall be counted as obtaining a credential, certification, or degree offered by a program of study or institution that was accredited by the entity during the period for which the report under this subparagraph is being submitted, if the student obtains such credential, certification, or degree after transferring to another institution during such period.]
[struck: the members of the postsecondary education governing body of the accrediting agency or association are not elected or selected by the board or chief executive officer of any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or membership organization;]
(2) [inserted: Authority to provide an accelerated path to recognition.—] [inserted: With respect to a prospective accrediting agency or association that submits to the Secretary an application for initial recognition under this Act, the Secretary may provide such recognition to such agency or association within 2 years after receipt of such application, if such application—]
(A) [inserted: demonstrates that the agency or association—]
(i) [inserted: has at least one year of experience in making accreditation or preaccreditation decisions; and]
(ii) [inserted: has policies in place that meet all the criteria under subsection (a) for recognition covering the range of the specific degrees, certificates, institutions, and programs of study for which the agency or association seeks such recognition; and]
(B) [inserted: provides an assurance that if the agency or association receives such recognition, the agency or association will submit to the Secretary monitoring reports regarding accreditation or preaccreditation decisions, as appropriate.]
[struck: among the membership of the board of the accrediting agency or association there shall be one public member (who is not a member of any related trade or membership organization) for each six members of the board, with a minimum of one such public member, and guidelines are established for such members to avoid conflicts of interest;]
(3) [inserted: Development of common terminology.—]
(A) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: Not later than 18 months after the date of enactment of the Accreditation Choice and Innovation Act, the Secretary shall—]
(i) [inserted: convene a panel of experts to develop common terminology for accrediting agencies or associations to use in making accrediting decisions with respect to programs of study and institutions, such as a common understanding of monitoring, warning, show cause, and other relevant statuses, as appropriate;]
(ii) [inserted: publish in the Federal Register with a 60-day public comment period, the recommendations for such common terminology; and]
(iii) [inserted: if the panel revises any recommendations published pursuant to clause (ii) based on the comments received during the 60-day public comment period, publish such revised recommendations in the Federal Register not later than 60 days after such 60-day comment period.]
(B) [inserted: Federal Advisory Committee Act.—] [inserted: Chapter 10 of title 5, United States Code, shall not apply to the panel convened under this paragraph.]
(C) [inserted: Termination.—] [inserted: The panel convened under this paragraph shall terminate on the date that is 60 days after the 60-day public comment period referred to in subparagraph (A)(ii).]
[struck: dues to the accrediting agency or association are paid separately from any dues paid to any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or membership organization; and]
[struck: (4)] [struck: the budget of the accrediting agency or association is developed and determined by the accrediting agency or association without review or resort to consultation with any other entity or organization.]
(c) Operating procedures required No accrediting agency or association may be recognized by the Secretary as a reliable authority as to the quality of education or training offered by an institution seeking to participate in the programs authorized under this subchapter, unless the agency or association—
(1) performs, at regularly established intervals[inserted: (which may vary based on institutional risk consistent with policies promulgated by the agency or association to determine such risk and interval frequency as authorized under subsection (p))], on-site inspections and reviews of institutions of higher education (which may include unannounced site visits) with particular focus on educational quality and program effectiveness, and ensures that accreditation team members are well-trained and knowledgeable with respect to their responsibilities[struck: , including those regarding distance education];
(2) [inserted: develops a policy process to identify any institution or program of study accredited by the agency or association that is not meeting the standards for accreditation of the agency or association, with a focus on the standards assessing an institution’s or program of study’s student success outcomes described in subsection (a)(5)(A)(i), which shall include—]
(A) [inserted: not less than annually, evaluating the extent to which such an identified institution or program of study continues to be in compliance with such standards or other indicators; and]
(B) [inserted: as appropriate, requiring the institution or program of study to submit a plan, on an annual basis, to the accrediting agency or association to—]
(i) [inserted: address and remedy performance issues with respect to such compliance; and]
(ii) [inserted: ensure that such plan is successfully implemented;]
[struck: (2)] [inserted: (3)] monitors the growth of programs at institutions that are experiencing significant enrollment growth;
[struck: (3)] [inserted: (4)] requires an institution to submit for approval to the accrediting agency a teach-out plan upon the occurrence of any of the following events:
(A) the Department notifies the accrediting agency of an action against the institution pursuant to section 1094(f) of this title;
(B) the accrediting agency acts to withdraw, terminate, or suspend the accreditation of the institution; or
(C) the institution notifies the accrediting agency that the institution intends to cease operations;
[struck: (4)] [inserted: (5)] [inserted: establishes and applies or maintains policies to ensure that any substantive change of an institution described in subparagraph (B) after the agency or association has granted the institution accreditation or preaccreditation status does not adversely affect the capacity of the institution to continue to meet the agency’s or association’s standards for such accreditation or preaccreditation status, which shall include policies that—]
(A) [inserted: require the institution to obtain the agency’s or association’s approval of the substantive change before the agency or association includes the change in the scope of the institution’s accreditation or preaccreditation status; and]
(B) [inserted: define substantive change to include—]
(i) [inserted: any change in the established mission or objectives of the institution;]
(ii) [inserted: any change in the legal status, form of control, or ownership of the institution, including the acquisition or addition of any other institution or new location where more than 50 percent of a program of study is offered;]
(iii) [inserted: changing the credential level offered by a program of study that was previously accredited by the agency or association when the program of study offered a different credential level; and]
(iv) [inserted: the entering into a contract under which another institution or an organization not eligible to participate in programs under this title offers more than 25 percent but less than 50 percent of the instruction of a program of study of the institution with such accreditation or preaccreditation status;]
[struck: requires that any institution of higher education subject to its jurisdiction which plans to establish a branch campus submit a business plan, including projected revenues and expenditures, prior to opening the branch campus;]
[struck: (5)] [inserted: (6)] agrees to conduct, as soon as practicable, but within a period of not more than 6 months of the establishment of a new branch campus or a change of ownership of an institution of higher education, an on-site visit of that branch campus or of the institution after a change of ownership;
[struck: (6)] [inserted: (7)] requires that teach-out agreements among institutions are subject to approval by the accrediting agency or association consistent with standards promulgated by such agency or association;
[struck: (7)] [inserted: (8)] makes available to the public[inserted: ,] [inserted: on the agency’s or association’s website, ]and the State licensing or authorizing agency, and submits to the Secretary, a summary of agency or association actions, including—
(A) the award of accreditation or reaccreditation of an institution;
(B) final denial, withdrawal, suspension, or termination of accreditation of an institution, and any findings made in connection with the action taken, together with the official comments of the affected institution; and
(C) any other adverse action taken with respect to an institution or placement on probation of an institution[inserted: , and a summary of why such action was taken or such placement was made];
[struck: (8)] [inserted: (9)] discloses publicly whenever an institution of higher education subject to its jurisdiction is being considered for accreditation or reaccreditation;[struck: and]
[struck: (9)] [inserted: (10)] confirms, as a part of the agency’s or association’s review for accreditation or reaccreditation, that the institution has transfer of credit policies—
(A) that are publicly disclosed; and
(B) that include a statement of the criteria established by the institution regarding the transfer of credit earned at another institution of higher education.
(11) [inserted: such agency or association shall make publicly available, on the agency or association’s website, a list of the institutions of higher education or program of study accredited by such agency or association, which includes, with respect to each such institution or program of study—]
(A) [inserted: the year accreditation was first granted;]
(B) [inserted: the most recent date that accreditation or reaccreditation was granted; and]
(C) [inserted: the anticipated date of the institution’s next evaluation for reaccreditation;]
(12) [inserted: confirms that the standards for accreditation of the agency or association do not assess the roles (including actions or statements) of elected and appointed State and Federal officials and legislative bodies; and]
(13) [inserted: confirms that an institution’s or program of study’s compliance with a standard for accreditation of the agency or association does not require the institution or program to take any action (such as developing a new program of study) that would result in a violation of any other such standard (including the standards for consideration of student success outcomes described in subsection (a)(5)(A)(i) that relate to comparing the median total price charged to students in a program of study student cohort to the value-added earnings of such cohort).]
(d) Length of recognition No accrediting agency or association may be recognized by the Secretary for the purpose of this chapter for a period of more than 5 years.
(e) Initial arbitration rule The Secretary may not recognize the accreditation of any institution of higher education unless the institution of higher education agrees to submit any dispute involving the final denial, withdrawal, or termination of accreditation to initial arbitration prior to any other legal action.
(f) Jurisdiction Notwithstanding any other provision of law, any civil action brought by an institution of higher education seeking accreditation from, or accredited by, an accrediting agency or association recognized by the Secretary for the purpose of this subchapter and involving the denial, withdrawal, or termination of accreditation of the institution of higher education, shall be brought in the appropriate United States district court.
(g) Limitation on scope of criteria[inserted: .—]
(1) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: The Secretary shall not establish criteria for accrediting agencies or associations that are not required by this section.]
(2) [inserted: Institutional eligibility.—] [inserted: An institution that is in compliance with the standards of its accrediting agency or association that assess the institution in accordance with subsection (a)(5) shall meet the accreditation requirements for certification as an institution of higher education under section 102 and subpart 3 of this part, regardless of any additional standards adopted by the agency or association for purposes unrelated to participation in programs under this Act.]
[struck: Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to permit the Secretary to establish criteria for accrediting agencies or associations that are not required by this section. Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to prohibit or limit any accrediting agency or association from adopting additional standards not provided for in this section. Nothing in this section shall be construed to permit the Secretary to establish any criteria that specifies, defines, or prescribes the standards that accrediting agencies or associations shall use to assess any institution’s success with respect to student achievement.]
(h) Change of accrediting agency[inserted: or association.—]
(1) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: With respect to an institution or program of study that is not subject to a covered action and that seeks to change its accrediting agency or association for a reason not related to any such covered action (such as compliance with State law)—]
(A) [inserted: the Secretary shall recognize the accreditation of such institution or program of study while the institution or program is in the process of changing its accrediting agency or association as long as, not later than 10 days before the start of such process, the institution or program of study provides written notification to the Secretary of such process; and]
(B) [inserted: such institution or program may make such a change without the approval of the Secretary as long as, not later than 10 days after the accreditation decision by the new accrediting agency or association, the institution or program and such new accrediting agency or association, provide written notification to the Secretary of the effective date of the accreditation by such agency or association of such institution or program.]
(2) [inserted: Covered action defined.—] [inserted: For purposes of this subsection, the term “covered action” means one or more of the following, when used with respect to an institution or program of study:]
(A) [inserted: A pending or final action brought by a State agency to suspend, revoke, withdraw, or terminate the institution’s legal authority to provide postsecondary education in the State.]
(B) [inserted: A decision by a recognized accrediting agency or association to deny accreditation or preaccreditation to the institution or program of study.]
(C) [inserted: A pending or final action brought by a recognized accrediting agency or association to suspend, revoke, withdraw, or terminate the accreditation or preaccreditation of the institution or program of study.]
(D) [inserted: Probation or an equivalent status imposed on the institution or program of study by a recognized accrediting agency or association.]
(E) [inserted: The institution is in the process of a substantive change (as described in subsection (c)(5)).]
[struck: The Secretary shall not recognize the accreditation of any otherwise eligible institution of higher education if the institution of higher education is in the process of changing its accrediting agency or association, unless the eligible institution submits to the Secretary all materials relating to the prior accreditation, including materials demonstrating reasonable cause for changing the accrediting agency or association.]
(i) Dual accreditation rule[inserted: .—]
(1) [inserted: Recognition by secretary.—] [inserted: The Secretary shall recognize the accreditation of any otherwise eligible institution of higher education if the institution of higher education is accredited, as an institution, by more than one accrediting agency or association.]
(2) [inserted: Designation by institution.—] [inserted: If the institution is accredited, as an institution, by more than one accrediting agency or association, the institution—]
(A) [inserted: shall—]
(i) [inserted: designate which agency’s or association’s accreditation shall be utilized in determining the institution’s eligibility for participation in programs under this Act; and]
(ii) [inserted: the period such agency’s or association’s accreditation shall be so utilized; and]
(B) [inserted: after the period described in subparagraph (A)(ii), the institution may designate a different agency’s or association’s accreditation to be utilized in accordance with subparagraph (A)(i).]
[struck: The Secretary shall not recognize the accreditation of any otherwise eligible institution of higher education if the institution of higher education is accredited, as an institution, by more than one accrediting agency or association, unless the institution submits to each such agency and association and to the Secretary the reasons for accreditation by more than one such agency or association and demonstrates to the Secretary reasonable cause for its accreditation by more than one agency or association. If the institution is accredited, as an institution, by more than one accrediting agency or association, the institution shall designate which agency’s accreditation shall be utilized in determining the institution’s eligibility for programs under this chapter.]
(j) Impact of loss of accreditation An institution may not be certified or recertified as an institution of higher education under section 1002 of this title and subpart 3 of this part or participate in any of the other programs authorized by this chapter if such institution—
(1) is not currently accredited by any agency or association recognized by the Secretary;
(2) has had its accreditation withdrawn, revoked, or otherwise terminated for cause during the preceding 24 months, unless such withdrawal, revocation, or termination has been rescinded by the same accrediting agency; or
(3) has withdrawn from accreditation voluntarily under a show cause or suspension order during the preceding 24 months, unless such order has been rescinded by the same accrediting agency.
(k) Religious institution rule[inserted: .—] [struck: Notwithstanding subsection (j), the Secretary shall allow an institution that has had its accreditation withdrawn, revoked, or otherwise terminated, or has voluntarily withdrawn from an accreditation agency, to remain certified as an institution of higher education under section 1002 of this title and subpart 3 of this part for a period sufficient to allow such institution to obtain alternative accreditation, if the Secretary determines that the reason for the withdrawal, revocation, or termination—]
(1) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: Notwithstanding subsection (j), the Secretary shall allow an institution that has had its accreditation withdrawn, revoked, or otherwise terminated, or has voluntarily withdrawn from an accreditation agency, to remain certified as an institution of higher education under section 102 and subpart 3 of this part for a period sufficient to allow such institution to obtain alternative accreditation, if the Secretary determines, in accordance with paragraph (2), that such withdrawal, revocation, or termination—]
(A) [inserted: is related to the religious mission or affiliation of the institution; and]
(B) [inserted: is not related to the accreditation criteria provided for in this section.]
[struck: is related to the religious mission or affiliation of the institution; and]
(2) [inserted: Administrative complaint for failure to respect religious mission.—]
(A) [inserted: In general.—]
(i) [inserted: Institution.—] [inserted: If an institution of higher education believes that an adverse action of an accrediting agency or association fails to respect the institution’s religious mission in violation of subsection (a)(4)(B), the institution—]
(I) [inserted: may file a complaint with the Secretary to review the adverse action of the agency or association; and]
(II) [inserted: prior to filing such complaint, shall notify the Secretary and the agency or association of an intent to file such complaint not later than 30 days after—]
(aa) [inserted: receiving the adverse action from the agency or association; or]
(bb) [inserted: determining that discussions with or the processes of the agency or association to remedy the failure to respect the religious mission of the institution will fail to result in the withdrawal of the adverse action by the agency or association.]
(ii) [inserted: Accrediting agency or association.—] [inserted: Upon notification of an intent to file a complaint and through the duration of the complaint process under this paragraph, the Secretary and the accrediting agency or association shall treat the accreditation status of the institution of higher education as if the adverse action for which the institution is filing the complaint had not been taken.]
(B) [inserted: Complaint.—] [inserted: Not later than 45 days after providing notice of the intent to file a complaint, the institution shall file the complaint with the Secretary (and provide a copy to the accrediting agency or association), which shall include—]
(i) [inserted: a description of the adverse action;]
(ii) [inserted: how the adverse action fails to respect the institution’s religious mission in violation of subsection (a)(4)(B); and]
(iii) [inserted: any other information the institution determines relevant to the complaint.]
(C) [inserted: Response.—]
(i) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: The accrediting agency or association shall have 30 days from the date the complaint is filed with the Secretary to file with the Secretary (and provide a copy to the institution) a response to the complaint, which response shall include—]
(I) [inserted: how the adverse action is based on a violation of the agency or association’s standards for accreditation; and]
(II) [inserted: how the adverse action does not fail to respect the religious mission of the institution and is in compliance with subsection (a)(4)(B).]
(ii) [inserted: Burden of proof.—]
(I) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: The accrediting agency or association shall bear the burden of proving that the agency or association has not taken the adverse action as a result of the institution’s religious mission, and that the action does not fail to respect the institution’s religious mission in violation of subsection (a)(4)(B), by showing that the adverse action does not impact the aspect of the religious mission claimed to be affected in the complaint.]
(II) [inserted: Insufficient proof.—] [inserted: Any evidence that the adverse action results from the application of a neutral and generally applicable rule shall be insufficient to prove that the action does not fail to respect an institution’s religious mission.]
(D) [inserted: Additional institution response.—]
(i) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: The institution shall have a 30-day period beginning on the date on which the agency or association’s response is filed with the Secretary to file with the Secretary (and provide a copy to the agency or association) a response to any issues raised in the response of the agency or association.]
(ii) [inserted: Waiver of right to respond.—] [inserted: An institution that does not file such a response during the 30-day period described in clause (i) shall be deemed to have waived the institution’s right to respond to the response of the agency or association.]
(E) [inserted: Secretarial action.—]
(i) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: Not later than 30 days after the institution submits a response pursuant to subparagraph (D)(i), or, in the case of an institution that waives the institution’s right to respond in accordance to subparagraph (D)(ii), 30 days after the date on which the agency or association’s response is filed with the Secretary—]
(I) [inserted: the Secretary shall review the materials to determine if the accrediting agency or association has met its burden of proof under subparagraph (C)(ii)(I); or]
(II) [inserted: in a case in which the Secretary fails to conduct such review—]
(aa) [inserted: the Secretary shall be deemed as determining that the adverse action fails to respect the religious mission of the institution; and]
(bb) [inserted: the accrediting agency or association shall be required to reverse the action immediately and take no further action with respect to such adverse action.]
(ii) [inserted: Review of complaint.—] [inserted: In reviewing the complaint under clause (i)(I)—]
(I) [inserted: the Secretary shall consider the institution to be correct in the assertion that the adverse action fails to respect the institution’s religious mission and shall apply the burden of proof described in subparagraph (C)(ii)(I) with respect to the accrediting agency or association; and]
(II) [inserted: if the Secretary determines that the accrediting agency or association fails to meet such burden of proof—]
(aa) [inserted: the Secretary shall notify the institution and the agency or association that the agency or association is not in compliance with subsection (a)(4)(B), and that such agency or association shall carry out the requirements of item (bb) to be in compliance with subsection (a)(4)(B); and]
(bb) [inserted: the agency or association shall reverse the adverse action immediately and take no further action with respect to such adverse action.]
(iii) [inserted: Final departmental action.—] [inserted: The Secretary’s determination under this subparagraph shall be the final action of the Department on the complaint.]
(F) [inserted: Rule of construction.—] [inserted: Nothing in this paragraph shall prohibit—]
(i) [inserted: an accrediting agency or association from taking an adverse action against an institution of higher education for a failure to comply with the agency or association’s standards of accreditation as long as such standards are in compliance with subsection (a)(4)(B) and any other applicable requirements of this section; or]
(ii) [inserted: an institution of higher education from exercising any other rights to address concerns with respect to an accrediting agency or association or the accreditation process of an accrediting agency or association.]
(G) [inserted: Regulations and guidance.—]
(i) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: The Secretary may only issue regulations and guidance under this paragraph that explain or clarify the process for providing a notice of an intent to file a complaint under this paragraph, and for preparing and filing such a complaint, a response to such complaint by an accrediting agency or association, and a response by an institution to a response filed by an accrediting agency or association.]
(ii) [inserted: Clarification.—] [inserted: The Secretary may not issue regulations, guidance, or otherwise determine or suggest, when discussions to remedy the failure by an accrediting agency or association to respect the religious mission of an institution of higher education referred to in subparagraph (A)(i)(II)(bb) have failed or will fail.]
[struck: is not related to the accreditation criteria provided for in this section.]
(l) Limitation, suspension, or termination of recognition
(1) If the Secretary determines that an accrediting agency or association has failed to apply effectively the criteria in this section, or is otherwise not in compliance with the requirements of this section, the Secretary shall—
§ 1099b(n)–(q)
(l)(1)(A)–(n)(1)(B) unchanged ·
(2) The Secretary shall place a priority for review of accrediting agencies or associations on those agencies or associations that accredit institutions of higher education that participate most extensively in the programs authorized by this subchapter and on those agencies or associations which have been the subject of the most complaints or legal actions.
(3) The Secretary shall consider all available relevant information concerning the compliance of the accrediting agency or association with the criteria provided for in this section, including any complaints or legal actions against such agency or association. In cases where deficiencies in the performance of an accreditation agency or association with respect to the requirements of this section are noted, the Secretary shall take these deficiencies into account in the recognition process. The Secretary shall not, under any circumstances, base decisions on the recognition or denial of recognition of accreditation agencies or associations on criteria other than those contained in this section. When the Secretary decides to recognize an accrediting agency or association, the Secretary shall determine the agency or association’s scope of recognition.[struck: If the agency or association reviews institutions offering distance education courses or programs and the Secretary determines that the agency or association meets the requirements of this section, then the agency shall be recognized and the scope of recognition shall include accreditation of institutions offering distance education courses or programs.]
(4) The Secretary shall maintain sufficient documentation to support the conclusions reached in the recognition process, and, if the Secretary does not recognize any accreditation agency or association, shall make publicly available the reason for denying recognition, including reference to the specific criteria under this section which have not been fulfilled.
(o) Regulations The Secretary shall by regulation provide procedures for the recognition of accrediting agencies or associations and for the appeal of the Secretary’s decisions. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the Secretary shall not promulgate any regulation with respect to the standards of an accreditation agency or association described in subsection (a)(5)[inserted: , or with respect to the policies and procedures of an accreditation agency or association described in paragraph (2) or (5) of subsection (c) or how the agency or association carries out such policies and procedures].
(p) [struck: Rule][inserted: Risk-based] [struck: of][inserted: or] [struck: construction][inserted: differentiated review processes or procedures.—] [struck: Nothing in subsection (a)(5) shall be construed to restrict the ability of—]
(1) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: Notwithstanding any other provision of law (including subsection (a)(4)(A)), an accrediting agency or association shall establish risk-based processes or procedures for assessing compliance with the accrediting agency or association’s standards (including policies related to substantive change and award of accreditation statuses) under which the agency or association—]
(A) [inserted: creates a system for understanding the performance of each institution and program of study being reviewed by such agency or association in comparison with the performance of other similarly situated institutions or programs of study (which may include the past performance of the institution or program with respect to meeting the accrediting agency or association’s standards, including the standards relating to the student success outcomes described in subsection (a)(5)(A)(i));]
(B) [inserted: with respect to each institution and program of study designated as high-risk, as determined using the accrediting agency or association’s system described in subparagraph (A), requires the institution and program of study to submit the annual plans described in subsection (c)(2)(B) to the agency or association that address the performance issues of such institution or program of study that resulted in such designation;]
(C) [inserted: with respect to each institution and program of study whose performance meets or exceeds the standards of the accrediting agency or association, as determined using the system described in subparagraph (A), reduces any compliance requirements with respect to such standards that are not assessing the institution or program of study in accordance with subsection (a)(5) (such as on-site inspections); and]
(D) [inserted: may require an institution or program of study that is required to submit an annual plan under subsection (c)(2)(B) (such as an institution or program that has a high-risk designation described in subparagraph (B)) and that has not improved as required by such annual plan, to take actions to avoid or minimize the risks that may lead to revocation of accreditation (such as limiting certain program of study enrollment or recommending to the Secretary to limit funds under this title for such an institution or program).]
[struck: an accrediting agency or association to set, with the involvement of its members, and to apply, accreditation standards for or to institutions or programs that seek review by the agency or association; or]
(2) [inserted: Prohibition.—] [struck: an][inserted: Any] [struck: institution][inserted: risk-based] [struck: to][inserted: review] [struck: develop][inserted: process] [struck: and][inserted: or] [struck: use][inserted: procedure] [struck: institutional][inserted: established] [struck: standards][inserted: pursuant] to [struck: show][inserted: this] [struck: its][inserted: subsection] [struck: success][inserted: shall] [struck: with][inserted: not] [struck: respect][inserted: discriminate] [struck: to][inserted: against,] [struck: student][inserted: or] [struck: achievement][inserted: otherwise preclude], [struck: which][inserted: institutions] [struck: achievement][inserted: of] [struck: may][inserted: higher] [struck: be][inserted: education] [struck: considered][inserted: based] [struck: as][inserted: on] [struck: part][inserted: institutional] [inserted: sector or category, including an institution ]of [struck: any][inserted: higher] [struck: accreditation][inserted: education’s] [struck: review][inserted: tax status].
(q) [struck: Review of scope changes][inserted: Definitions.—] [inserted: For purposes of this section:]
(1) [inserted: Program length.—] [inserted: The term ‘program length’ means the minimum amount of time in weeks, months, or years that is specified in the catalog, marketing materials, or other official publications of an institution of higher education for a full-time student to complete the requirements for a specific program of study.]
(2) [inserted: Program of study.—]
(A) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: The term “program of study” means an eligible program at an institution of higher education that is classified by a combination of—]
(i) [inserted: one or more CIP codes; and]
(ii) [inserted: one credential level, determined by the credential awarded upon completion of the program.]
(B) [inserted: CIP CODE.—] [inserted: The term “CIP code” means the six-digit taxonomic identification code assigned by an institution of higher education to a specific program of study at the institution, determined by the institution of higher education in accordance with the Classification of Instructional Programs published by the National Center for Education Statistics.]
(C) [inserted: Credential level.—]
(i) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: The term “credential level” means the level of the degree or other credential awarded by an institution of higher education to students who complete a program of study of the institution. Each degree or other credential awarded by an institution shall be categorized by the institution as either undergraduate credential level or graduate credential level.]
(ii) [inserted: Undergraduate credential.—] [inserted: When used with respect to a credential or credential level, the term `undergraduate credential' includes credentials such as an undergraduate certificate, an associate degree, a bachelor’s degree, and a post-baccalaureate certificate (including the coursework specified in paragraphs (3)(B) and (4)(B) of section 484(b)).]
(iii) [inserted: Graduate credential.—] [inserted: When used with respect to a credential or credential level, the term “graduate credential” includes credentials such as a master’s degree, a doctoral degree, a professional degree, and a postgraduate certificate.]
(3) [inserted: Program of study student cohort.—]
(A) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: The term “program of study student cohort” means the cohort of individuals who completed a specific program of study at an institution of higher education during the same award year, except that such cohort shall only include an individual who received Federal financial aid under this title during the period the individual was enrolled in such program of study.]
(B) [inserted: Small cohorts.—] [inserted: With respect to such a program of study student cohort that has fewer than 30 individuals, the Secretary shall aggregate additional years of data for the program of study in order to achieve a cohort of at least 30 individuals.]
(4) [inserted: Religious mission.—] [inserted: The term “religious mission”—]
(A) [inserted: means a published institutional mission that is approved by the governing body of an institution of higher education and that includes, refers to, or is predicated upon religious tenets, beliefs, or teachings; and]
(B) [inserted: may be reflected in any of the institution’s policies, decisions, or practices related to such tenets, beliefs, or teachings (including any policies or decisions concerning housing, employment, curriculum, self-governance, or student admission, continuing enrollment, or graduation).]
(5) [inserted: Total price.—] [inserted: With respect to a student who received Federal financial assistance under this title and who completes a program of study, the term ‘total price’ means the total amount, before Federal financial assistance under this title was applied, a student was required to pay to complete the program of study. A student’s total price shall be calculated by the Secretary as the difference between—]
(A) [inserted: the total amount of tuition and fees that were charged to such student before the application of any Federal financial assistance provided under this title; minus]
(B) [inserted: the total amount of grants and scholarships described in section 480(i) awarded to such student from non-Federal sources for such program of study.]
(6) [inserted: Value-added earnings.—]
(A) [inserted: Value-added earnings.—]
(i) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: The term “value-added earnings” mean—]
(I) [inserted: the median annual earnings of a program of study student cohort, as adjusted pursuant to clause (iii) (as appropriate), minus]
(II) [inserted: the product of—]
(aa) [inserted: the poverty line applicable to a single individual, (as determined under section 673(2) of the Community Services Block Grant Act (42 U.S.C. 9902(2))) for the year in which such earnings were measured; and]
(bb) [inserted: the applicable percentage described in clause (ii).]
(ii) [inserted: Applicable percentage.—] [inserted: The applicable percentage described in this clause is—]
(I) [inserted: in the case of a program of study student cohort for program of study that awards an undergraduate credential, 150 percent; and]
(II) [inserted: in the case of a program of study student cohort for a program of study that awards a graduate credential, 300 percent.]
(iii) [inserted: Geographic adjustment.—] [inserted: Except in the case of a program of study student cohort in which 50 percent or more of the individuals in such cohort participated exclusively online, the Secretary shall adjust the median annual earnings of a program of study student cohort by the regional price parity index of the Bureau of Economic Analysis for the metropolitan statistical area in which the institution offering such program is located.]
(B) [inserted: Annual earnings.—]
(i) [inserted: Annual earnings.—] [inserted: The term “annual earnings” means the earnings of an individual who is in a program of study student cohort, who is working, and who is not enrolled at an institution, measured—]
(I) [inserted: in the case of an undergraduate certificate, post-baccalaureate certificate, or graduate certificate, 1 year after completion of such program;]
(II) [inserted: in the case of an associates or masters degree, 2 years after completion of such program; and]
(III) [inserted: in the case of bachelor’s degree, doctoral degree, or professional degree, 4 years after completion of such program.]
(ii) [inserted: Exception.—] [inserted: The Secretary may, as the Secretary determines appropriate based on the characteristics of a program of study, extend the applicable measurement period under clause (i) for a program of study that—]
(I) [inserted: requires completion of an additional educational program (such as a residency or fellowship) after completion of the program of study in order to obtain licensure or board certification associated with the credential awarded for such program of study; and]
(II) [inserted: when combined with the program length of such additional educational program for licensure or board certification, has a total program length that exceeds the applicable measurement period under clause (i) for such program of study,]
[inserted: except that in no case shall the annual earnings of an individual be measured more than 1 year after the individual completes such additional educational program.]
[struck: The Secretary shall require a review, at the next available meeting of the National Advisory Committee on Institutional Quality and Integrity, of any change in scope undertaken by an agency or association under subsection (a)(4)(B)(i)(II) if the enrollment of an institution that offers distance education or correspondence education that is accredited by such agency or association increases by 50 percent or more within any one institutional fiscal year.]