Changes to the Code
S. 1569 · Fairness in Higher Education Accreditation Act · Introduced The text as a member of Congress first filed it. Most bills never get further than this.
In committee · step 2 of 5
20 U.S.C. § 1099b Recognition of accrediting agency or association
8 changes the bill asks for here, 7 carried out
- Carried out:
in subparagraph (I), by striking
and
after the semicolon;
- Carried out:
in subparagraph (J), by inserting
and
after the semicolon;
and - Not carried out:
by inserting after subparagraph (J), and before the flush text, the following:
(K) except in the case of an institution described in subsection (r)(2), success in ensuring a right of free inquiry (as defined in subsection (r)(1));;
We can't read how this instruction is worded yet, so it isn't shown in the text.
Technical detail
no-pattern: inserting after subparagraph (X), and before the flush text, the following: QCONTENT; - Carried out:
in paragraph (7), by striking
and
after the semicolon;
- Carried out:
in paragraph (8), by striking the period at the end and inserting
; and
; and - Carried out:
by adding at the end the following:
(9) the accrediting agency or association will not impose requirements, establish standards, conduct investigations, or make recommendations concerning— (A) the race, color, sex, or national origin composition of the student body, faculty, or staff; (B) the race, color, sex, or …
- Carried out:
in subsection (p), by striking
Nothing in subsection (a)(5)
and insertingSubject to subsection (a)(9), nothing in subsection (a)(5)
; and - Carried out:
by adding at the end the following:
(r) Free inquiry.— (1) Free inquiry.— In this section, the term “free inquiry” means— (A) in the case of a public institution of higher education that is legally required to abide by the First Amendment to the Constitution, compliance with— (i) the First Amendment to the …
§ 1099b(a)Criteria required(5)–(6)
Start of § 1099b to (a)(5)(G) unchanged
| Where | Mark | The Code now | Mark | As the bill would leave it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (5)(H) | (H) | (H) | ||
| measures of program length and the objectives of the degrees or credentials offered; | measures of program length and the objectives of the degrees or credentials offered; | |||
| (5)(I) | (I) | (I) | ||
| record of student complaints received by, or available to, the agency or association; | record of student complaints received by, or available to, the agency or association; | |||
| (5)(J) | (J) | (J) | ||
| record of compliance with its program responsibilities under this subchapter based on the most recent student loan default rate data provided by the Secretary, the results of financial or compliance audits, program reviews, and such other information as the Secretary may provide to the agency or association; | record of compliance with its program responsibilities under this subchapter based on the most recent student loan default rate data provided by the Secretary, the results of financial or compliance audits, program reviews, and such other information as the Secretary may provide to the agency or association;[inserted: and] | |||
| (5) | except that subparagraphs (A), (H), and (J) shall not apply to agencies or associations described in paragraph (2)(A)(ii) of this subsection; | except that subparagraphs (A), (H), and (J) shall not apply to agencies or associations described in paragraph (2)(A)(ii) of this subsection; | ||
| (6) | (6) | (6) | ||
| such an agency or association shall establish and apply review procedures throughout the accrediting process, including evaluation and withdrawal proceedings, which comply with due process procedures that provide— | such an agency or association shall establish and apply review procedures throughout the accrediting process, including evaluation and withdrawal proceedings, which comply with due process procedures that provide— |
§ 1099b(a)–(b)
(a)(6)(A)–(F) unchanged
| Where | Mark | The Code now | Mark | As the bill would leave it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (a)(6)(G) | (G) | (G) | ||
| that any determination by the agency or association made with respect to the new financial information described in subparagraph (E) shall not be separately appealable by the institution or program; | that any determination by the agency or association made with respect to the new financial information described in subparagraph (E) shall not be separately appealable by the institution or program; | |||
| (a)(7) | (7) | (7) | ||
| such agency or association shall notify the Secretary and the appropriate State licensing or authorizing agency within 30 days of the accreditation of an institution or any final denial, withdrawal, suspension, or termination of accreditation or placement on probation of an institution, together with any other adverse action taken with respect to an institution; | such agency or association shall notify the Secretary and the appropriate State licensing or authorizing agency within 30 days of the accreditation of an institution or any final denial, withdrawal, suspension, or termination of accreditation or placement on probation of an institution, together with any other adverse action taken with respect to an institution; | |||
| (a)(8) | (8) | (8) | ||
| such agency or association shall make available to the public, upon request, and to the Secretary, and the State licensing or authorizing agency a summary of any review resulting in a final accrediting decision involving denial, termination, or suspension of accreditation, together with the comments of the affected institution | such agency or association shall make available to the public, upon request, and to the Secretary, and the State licensing or authorizing agency a summary of any review resulting in a final accrediting decision involving denial, termination, or suspension of accreditation, together with the comments of the affected institution[inserted: ; and] | |||
| (a)(9) | (9) [inserted: ] | |||
| [inserted: the accrediting agency or association will not impose requirements, establish standards, conduct investigations, or make recommendations concerning—] | ||||
| (a)(9)(A) | (A) [inserted: ] | |||
| [inserted: the race, color, sex, or national origin composition of the student body, faculty, or staff;] | ||||
| (a)(9)(B) | (B) [inserted: ] | |||
| [inserted: the race, color, sex, or national origin of the students, faculty members, or staff members who are in leadership roles; or] | ||||
| (a)(9)(C) | (C) [inserted: ] | |||
| [inserted: the race, color, sex, or national origin of the students, faculty members, or staff members who receive honors or special commendations;] | ||||
| (a)(10) | (10) [inserted: ] | |||
| [inserted: an accrediting agency or association may only be determined to be a reliable authority as to the quality of education or training offered for the purposes of this Act or for other Federal purposes if the agency or association permits each institution of higher education that the agency or association accredits (and each component or subpart of each institution of higher education that the agency or association accredits) to adopt any lawful policy with regard to the factors described in subparagraphs (A) through (C) of paragraph (9), notwithstanding the particular mission of an institution of higher education (or component or subpart thereof); and] | ||||
| (a)(11) | (11) [inserted: ] | |||
| [inserted: as part of the accrediting process, an accrediting agency or association may not consider any factor described in subparagraphs (A) through (C) of paragraph (9).] | ||||
| (b) | (b) “Separate and independent” defined | (b) “Separate and independent” defined | ||
| For the purpose of subsection (a)(3), the term “separate and independent” means that— | For the purpose of subsection (a)(3), the term “separate and independent” means that— | |||
| (b)(1) | (1) | (1) | ||
| the members of the postsecondary education governing body of the accrediting agency or association are not elected or selected by the board or chief executive officer of any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or membership organization; | the members of the postsecondary education governing body of the accrediting agency or association are not elected or selected by the board or chief executive officer of any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or membership organization; | |||
§ 1099b(o)–(r)
(b)(2)–(n)(4) unchanged
| Where | Mark | The Code now | Mark | As the bill would leave it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (o) | (o) Regulations | (o) Regulations | ||
| The Secretary shall by regulation provide procedures for the recognition of accrediting agencies or associations and for the appeal of the Secretary’s decisions. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the Secretary shall not promulgate any regulation with respect to the standards of an accreditation agency or association described in subsection (a)(5). | The Secretary shall by regulation provide procedures for the recognition of accrediting agencies or associations and for the appeal of the Secretary’s decisions. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the Secretary shall not promulgate any regulation with respect to the standards of an accreditation agency or association described in subsection (a)(5). | |||
| (p) | (p) Rule of construction | (p) Rule of construction | ||
| [inserted: Subject] [inserted: to subsection (a)(9), nothing ]in subsection (a)(5) shall be construed to restrict the ability of— | ||||
| (p)(1) | (1) | (1) | ||
| an accrediting agency or association to set, with the involvement of its members, and to apply, accreditation standards for or to institutions or programs that seek review by the agency or association; or | an accrediting agency or association to set, with the involvement of its members, and to apply, accreditation standards for or to institutions or programs that seek review by the agency or association; or | |||
| (p)(2) | (2) | (2) | ||
| an institution to develop and use institutional standards to show its success with respect to student achievement, which achievement may be considered as part of any accreditation review. | an institution to develop and use institutional standards to show its success with respect to student achievement, which achievement may be considered as part of any accreditation review. | |||
| (q) | (q) Review of scope changes | (q) Review of scope changes | ||
| The Secretary shall require a review, at the next available meeting of the National Advisory Committee on Institutional Quality and Integrity, of any change in scope undertaken by an agency or association under subsection (a)(4)(B)(i)(II) if the enrollment of an institution that offers distance education or correspondence education that is accredited by such agency or association increases by 50 percent or more within any one institutional fiscal year. | The Secretary shall require a review, at the next available meeting of the National Advisory Committee on Institutional Quality and Integrity, of any change in scope undertaken by an agency or association under subsection (a)(4)(B)(i)(II) if the enrollment of an institution that offers distance education or correspondence education that is accredited by such agency or association increases by 50 percent or more within any one institutional fiscal year. | |||
| (r) | (r) [inserted: Free inquiry.—] | |||
| (r)(1) | (1) [inserted: Free inquiry.—] | |||
| [inserted: In this section, the term “free inquiry” means—] | ||||
| (r)(1)(A) | (A) [inserted: ] | |||
| [inserted: in the case of a public institution of higher education that is legally required to abide by the First Amendment to the Constitution, compliance with—] | ||||
| (r)(1)(A)(i) | (i) [inserted: ] | |||
| [inserted: the First Amendment to the Constitution, including protections for freedom of speech, association, press, religion, assembly, and petition; and] | ||||
| (r)(1)(A)(ii) | (ii) [inserted: ] | |||
| [inserted: the institution’s own written policies regarding academic freedom; or] | ||||
| (r)(1)(B) | (B) [inserted: ] | |||
| [inserted: in the case of a private institution of higher education, adherence to the institution’s written institutional policies concerning freedom of speech, association, press, religion, assembly, petition, and academic freedom.] | ||||
| (r)(2) | (2) [inserted: Religious exemption.—] | |||
| [inserted: An institution described in any of subparagraphs (A) through (F) shall not be subject to the free inquiry requirements of subsection (a)(5)(K). Such exempt institutions shall include an institution—] | ||||
| (r)(2)(A) | (A) [inserted: ] | |||
| [inserted: that is a school or department of divinity;] | ||||
| (r)(2)(B) | (B) [inserted: ] | |||
| [inserted: that requires its faculty, students, or employees to be members of, or otherwise engage in religious practices of, or espouse a personal belief in, the religion of the organization by which it claims to be controlled;] | ||||
| (r)(2)(C) | (C) [inserted: ] | |||
| [inserted: that in its charter or catalog, or other official publication, contains an explicit statement that it is controlled by a religious organization or an organ thereof, or is committed to the doctrines or practices of a particular religion, and the members of its governing body are appointed by the controlling religious organization or an organ thereof, and it receives a significant amount of financial support from the controlling religious organization or an organ thereof;] | ||||
| (r)(2)(D) | (D) [inserted: ] | |||
| [inserted: that has a doctrinal statement or a statement of religious practices, along with a statement that members of the institution community must engage in the religious practices of, or espouse a personal belief in, the religion, its practices, or the doctrinal statement or statement of religious practices;] | ||||
| (r)(2)(E) | (E) [inserted: ] | |||
| [inserted: that has a published institutional mission that is approved by the governing body of an educational institution and that includes, refers to, or is predicated upon religious tenets, beliefs, or teachings; or] | ||||
| (r)(2)(F) | (F) [inserted: ] | |||
| [inserted: with respect to which there is other evidence sufficient to establish that the institution is controlled by a religious organization, pursuant to section 901(a)(3) of the Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. 1681(a)(3)).] | ||||