Changes to the Code
S. 5148 · Blocking Overt Attempts at Shopping By Enforcing Randomization Guidelines Act · Introduced The text as a member of Congress first filed it. Most bills never get further than this.
BOASBERG Act
In committee · step 2 of 5
28 U.S.C. § 137 Division of business among district judges
1 change the bill asks for here, 1 carried out
- Carried out:
Section 137 of title 28, United States Code, is amended by adding at the end the following:
(c) Random assignment of civil proceedings.— (1) In general.— Notwithstanding subsection (a), all district courts shall adopt and observe a rule mandating the random assignment of all civil cases. The rule shall ensure that no party, attorney, or judge (including a chief judge) …
§ 137(b)–(d)
Start of § 137 to (b)(1)(B)(ii) unchanged ·
(C) Exception.— Subparagraph (B) does not apply to an application to determine reasonable license fees made by individual proprietors under section 513 of title 17.
(2) Rule of construction.— Nothing in paragraph (1) shall modify the rights of any party to a consent decree or to a proceeding to determine reasonable license fees, to make an application for the construction of any provision of the applicable consent decree. Such application shall be referred to the judge to whom continuing jurisdiction over the applicable consent decree is currently assigned. If any such application is made in connection with a rate proceeding, such rate proceeding shall be stayed until the final determination of the construction application. Disputes in connection with a rate proceeding about whether a licensee is similarly situated to another licensee shall not be subject to referral to the judge with continuing jurisdiction over the applicable consent decree.
(c) [inserted: Random assignment of civil proceedings.—]
(1) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: Notwithstanding subsection (a), all district courts shall adopt and observe a rule mandating the random assignment of all civil cases. The rule shall ensure that no party, attorney, or judge (including a chief judge) may select, direct, or influence the assignment of any case to a particular judge.]
(2) [inserted: Exceptions.—] [inserted: A case may be reassigned from its randomly assigned judge only under the following circumstances:]
(A) [inserted: If the assigned judge is required to recuse or is otherwise disqualified under Federal law or judicial ethics rules.]
(B) [inserted: If a case is substantially related to a currently pending case before another judge in the same district, the assigned judge may, at the discretion of that judge, consolidate or reassign the case for judicial efficiency if the court issues a memorandum required under paragraph (5)(B).]
(C) [inserted: If the chief judge of the district, publicly and with the consent of a majority of active judges in the district, certifies that for good cause and in the interest of docket efficiency a case needs to be reassigned from the randomly assigned judge, provided that the reassignment is not based on the identity of the parties or attorneys involved or the nature or subject matter of the case.]
(D) [inserted: In a circumstance described in subsection (d)(2).]
(3) [inserted: Declining a case assignment.—] [inserted: A judge may not decline a case after the case has been randomly assigned to that judge. A judge designated as the emergency on-call judge for a period may not decline a case assigned during that period.]
(4) [inserted: Rules for chief judges.—] [inserted: A chief judge of a district court shall not self-assign cases outside the randomized process. The chief judge of a district court shall not use the position of chief judge to influence the assignment of any case.]
(5) [inserted: Transparency.—]
(A) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: All district courts shall publicly post and disclose any rules, orders, policies, or plans regarding the assignment of civil cases.]
(B) [inserted: Memorandum.—] [inserted: In any civil case where a judge cannot be randomly assigned, or a case is reassigned, the district court shall publicly issue a memorandum indicating that fact and explaining why the case could not be randomly assigned or was reassigned.]
(C) [inserted: No posting of rules.—]
(i) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: To prevent circumvention of random case assignment, district courts shall not publicly post or disclose any rules, orders, policies, or plans regarding the identity of the judge on-call for emergencies.]
(ii) [inserted: Rule of construction.—] [inserted: Nothing in this subparagraph shall be interpreted to limit the requirements of subparagraphs (B) or (D).]
(D) [inserted: Statistical report.—] [inserted: The clerk of the court shall annually publish a statistical report summarizing case assignments, including reassignment rates and reasons for reassignments.]
(6) [inserted: Protecting random assignment.—] [inserted: Any attempt to manipulate or evade the randomized case assignment system shall be subject to—]
(A) [inserted: in the case of offending conduct by a lawyer, sanctions, including potential case dismissal or disciplinary action;]
(B) [inserted: in the case of offending conduct by a judge, the judicial misconduct process; or]
(C) [inserted: in the case of offending conduct by a court employee, disciplinary action, including potential termination of employment.]
(7) [inserted: Senior judges.—] [inserted: Case assignments for senior judges shall be random to the greatest extent possible. Nothing in this section shall be construed to impede the assignment of cases to senior judges.]
(8) [inserted: Rules of construction.—] [inserted: Nothing in this subsection shall be construed—]
(A) [inserted: to prevent district courts from assigning cases filed within a division to 1 or more judges; or]
(B) [inserted: to affect the ability of a senior judge to take on a reduced caseload.]
(d) [inserted: Reassignment after erroneous rulings.—]
(1) [inserted: In general.—] [inserted: Notwithstanding any other requirement, in any circumstance described in paragraph (2), a case or controversy shall be reassigned, through a random assignment process, from the assigned district judge to another district judge within the district. If no such judge is available in the same district, the case or controversy shall be reassigned, through a random assignment process, to another available district judge within the circuit, to the extent practicable and consistent with applicable law.]
(2) [inserted: Circumstances described.—] [inserted: The circumstances described in this paragraph are circumstances in which the Supreme Court of the United States—]
(A) [inserted: vacates or reverses, in whole or in part, the judgment of the district court;]
(B) [inserted: vacates or reverses, in whole or in part, an injunction granted by the district court;]
(C) [inserted: vacates or reverses, in whole or in part, the judgment of the court of appeals that affirmed the district court in relevant part;]
(D) [inserted: issues an extraordinary writ authorized by section 1651 in the case;]
(E) [inserted: issues a stay (other than an administrative stay) of an order of the district court;]
(F) [inserted: issues an injunction where the district court had declined to issue such an injunction;]
(G) [inserted: issues a writ of prohibition or mandamus involving the assigned district judge related to the case;]
(H) [inserted: issues a writ of habeas corpus where the district court declined to issue such a writ and the prisoner is a Federal officer described in section 1442.]
28 U.S.C. § 46 Assignment of judges; panels; hearings; quorum
The bill's words for this section
- Not carried out:
by striking (b) In and inserting the following:(b) (1) In; and
The bill gives this provision a heading and rewords it at the same time, a kind of change we can't show yet.
Technical detail
the provision inserted says more than a heading and the words struck - Not carried out:
by striking the third sentence and all that follows through the end and inserting the following:
(2) In each circuit, the court shall adopt and observe a rule providing for the random assignment of judges to such panels. The rule shall ensure that no party, attorney, or judge (including a chief judge) may select, direct, or influence the assignment of any judge to a …
We can't read how this instruction is worded yet, so it isn't shown in the text.
Technical detail
no-pattern: striking the third sentence and all that follows through the end and inserting the following: QCONTENT. QCONTENT.